Ignorance is Bliss and “Truth will prevail.”
Over the past few weeks I’ve been watching the reaction to Big Love’s “Outer Darkness” episode and have come to the conclusion that ignorance is both blissful and dangerous. I’m still at somewhat of a loss to understand why the producers felt it was necessary to include depictions of elements of the LDS Temple ceremonies. Forgeries are worthless to all but the ignorant - and it seems so in this case.
The blog traffic by non Mormons seems split between sympathy for Barb’s torn feelings and dismissive of the importance of the ritual. What is utterly lacking is any objective, informed discussion of whether or not there might be any substance to the subject. This is unfortunate, since there are qualified sources who have discussed the prevalence and history of signs, symbols and gestures in religious practice and fraternal organizations going back as far as the earliest civilizations; The Minoans’ (2700 to 1459 B.C) and Egyptians (3100 B.C. - 450 A.D.) both left evidence. J.S.M. Ward’s “Secret Sign Languages” contains several examples of just how ancient some of the gestures are - far predating the foundation of the modern Masonic order.
More recently, there has been enough information published to allow anyone to become informed on the content and scope of many symbolic rites, including the LDS and Mason’s, and develop an informed opinion on the similarities and differences. Further, the details of early LDS history are coming out in much greater depth, to the point where it’s possible to even pin down the date, time and place of events in the life of Joseph Smith which are related to the temple. In “The Diaries and Journals of Joseph Smith”, Scott Faulring noted that on March 15th and 16th, 1842 Joseph officiated at the installation of the Nauvoo Masonic Lodge and received the first three degrees of Masonry. This was *after* his references to the the grand Key-words of the Holy Priesthood and the temple were prepared for publication in the March 15th edition (Volume III No. 10) of the Times and Seasons. Clearly, Joseph knew about signs, tokens and key-words before his brief association with Masonry. Unfortunately he didn’t publically comment on Masonry, as far as we know. However, he openly emphasized how important it was for the Latter-Day Saints to obtain the knowledge available in the temple.
I note also that what was depicted in the Big Love episode bears no resemblance to any Masonic ritual which I am aware of. (See Michael Bradley’s “The Secrets of the Freemasons”)